# Kangana Ranaut Counterattacks Sharmila Tagore Over Vande Mataram Remark, Advises Against Viewing Art Through Religious Lens

> Following Sharmila Tagore's remarks on the national song Vande Mataram, Kangana Ranaut responded by stating that art should not be confined by religious boundaries. Kangana was also recently in the spotlight due to her verbal spat with Baba Ramdev.

**Type:** article · **Category:** Bollywood · **Published:** 2026-08-21 · **Source:** TrendKia
**Canonical:** https://trendkia.com/en/bollywood/sharmila-tagore-ki-vande-mataram-tippani-para-kangana-ranaut-ka-palatavara-kaha-kala-ko-dharmika-chashme-se-na-dekhen-19528 · **Language:** English
**Tags:** Kangana Ranaut, Sharmila Tagore, Vande Mataram, Baba Ramdev, Bollywood, National Song

The ongoing debate regarding the national song Vande Mataram has extended beyond political corridors, with prominent figures from the Indian film industry actively sharing their perspectives. Following her recent public controversy involving yoga guru Baba Ramdev, actress Kangana Ranaut has now responded to comments made by veteran actress Sharmila Tagore. Tagore had expressed religious reservations regarding certain portions of the composition, prompting Kangana to emphasize that artistic and literary works should not be judged through a strictly religious lens.

## Kangana Ranaut Responds to Sharmila Tagore's Views
During an interview, Sharmila Tagore shared her thoughts on Vande Mataram, stating that individuals who adhere to monotheism might not find the song's references to various deities comfortable. She noted that reciting phrases such as 'Vande Kali' or 'Vande Durga' could present difficulties for such believers. However, Tagore also acknowledged that when viewed inclusively across communities, the first two stanzas of the song are commendable. After the video of this interaction circulated, Kangana Ranaut shared a detailed message on her official Instagram account outlining her disagreement.

## The Significance of Artistic Expression and Metaphor
In her Instagram story, Kangana Ranaut noted that while she appreciated Tagore's willingness to state her opinion clearly, she was surprised by her viewpoint as a fellow artist. Kangana asserted that words utilized in poetry and music function primarily as symbols and metaphors created through artistic imagination. She highlighted that Bankim Chandra Chattopadhyay composed Vande Mataram during the freedom movement to awaken inner strength and collective consciousness across the nation. Kangana questioned why such an influential work of art should be restricted to a narrow interpretation of religious practice.

## Reference to Swami Vivekananda and Unity
To support her argument, Kangana Ranaut cited Swami Vivekananda, noting that the concept of strength extends beyond religious frameworks. She encouraged people to transcend rigid communal perspectives and foster mutual understanding. Kangana maintained that literary creations should not always be interpreted literally, but rather understood through their broader thematic intent. Sharmila Tagore has not issued a public response to Kangana's statements.

## Previous Verbal Spat With Baba Ramdev
This discussion follows Kangana Ranaut's recent public dispute with Baba Ramdev. After Ramdev criticized Kangana over her 'gutter generation' remark and questioned her background and past statements, Kangana issued a sharp response. She advised Ramdev to refrain from making personal remarks about her life, pointing out that unlike his organization, she had never faced reprimands from the Supreme Court over misleading medical claims.

## The Broader Context of the Vande Mataram Debate
The discussion surrounding Vande Mataram touches upon history, nationalism, faith, and artistic freedom. While many view the composition as an essential element of the independence movement and a revered national song, specific stanzas have historically invited varying interpretations. Differing opinions have also surfaced within political parties, including Congress. The exchange between Sharmila Tagore and Kangana Ranaut brings these historical and cultural questions back into mainstream public discourse.

## What this means for you
- **Across India:** This controversy highlights ongoing national conversations surrounding the national song, freedom of expression, and artistic interpretation.
- **In Entertainment:** It underscores the growing intersection of art and politics, where prominent personalities actively voice opinions on socio-political themes.

## Questions & Answers

### 1. What objection did Sharmila Tagore raise regarding Vande Mataram?
Sharmila Tagore stated that for believers in monotheism, references to deities in the song might not feel comfortable, making phrases like 'Vande Kali' or 'Vande Durga' difficult to recite.

### 2. How did Kangana Ranaut respond to Sharmila Tagore's remarks?
Kangana Ranaut argued that words in poetry and songs serve as symbols and metaphors, asserting that art and Bankim Chandra Chattopadhyay's work should not be restricted to a religious lens.

### 3. What was the previous dispute between Kangana Ranaut and Baba Ramdev?
After Baba Ramdev criticized Kangana's 'gutter generation' statement, Kangana retaliated by noting that she had never been reprimanded by the Supreme Court over false medical claims.

### 4. What did Sharmila Tagore say about the initial stanzas of Vande Mataram?
Sharmila Tagore acknowledged that when considering all communities together, the first two stanzas of Vande Mataram are quite positive.

---
_TrendKia — Har trend, sabse pehle.. Machine-readable view; canonical HTML at the URL above._