Haryana Moves To Contest Private Power Licence For Gurugram And Nuh Before Appellate Tribunal The Haryana government will appeal before the Appellate Tribunal for Electricity against a regulatory decision granting a parallel power distribution licence to Eleven Power for Gurugram and Nuh. The Haryana state administration has decided to initiate formal legal proceedings against a recent regulatory order that authorised a private firm to operate as a parallel electricity distributor across two major districts. Haryana Energy Minister Anil Vij confirmed that the state government is preparing an appeal before the Appellate Tribunal for Electricity, commonly known as APTEL. The legal challenge directly contests an approval granted by the Haryana Electricity Regulatory Commission, which permits private entry into the electricity distribution network of Gurugram and Nuh. Regulatory Approval And Licensing Details The controversy stems from an official order issued by the Haryana Electricity Regulatory Commission under Section 14 of the Electricity Act, 2003. According to Eleven Power Private Limited, the commission issued the order granting it a parallel electricity distribution licence on October 19. The regulatory licence covers the complete revenue territories of both Gurugram and Nuh districts and is scheduled to remain valid for a duration of 25 years. Following the receipt of the licence, Eleven Power Private Limited outlined its capital allocation and deployment roadmap for the region. The private enterprise announced intentions to invest Rs 4,717 crore across a five-year development phase to build its dedicated power distribution network and supporting infrastructure. The company indicated that its distribution operations and commercial electricity supply to local consumers are anticipated to commence during the 2027-28 fiscal period. State Government Stance And Ministerial Reaction Energy Minister Anil Vij made the decision public through a post written in Hindi on the social media platform X, stating unequivocally that the administration would contest the regulatory commission's directive before the electricity tribunal. The minister pointed out that the state government had maintained consistent opposition to introducing a second distribution licensee in these two sensitive and economically critical districts. Vij noted that the initial licence application was submitted directly to the Haryana Electricity Regulatory Commission by the private applicant rather than routing through the state Energy Department. The commission operates as an autonomous regulatory institution under the law. When the commission subsequently sought the formal response and observations of the Haryana government regarding the proposed parallel licensing, the state administration objected to the proposal on every single point, maintaining an unbroken record of opposition throughout the regulatory review process. The Mechanics Of Parallel Electricity Distribution The operational framework of a parallel distribution licence differs fundamentally from a privatization or asset handover. The state-owned utility, Dakshin Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam, currently manages power supply across Gurugram and Nuh. The regulatory grant awarded to Eleven Power Private Limited does not displace, dissolve, or replace the state utility. Instead, it allows a commercial entity to establish parallel infrastructure and compete within the identical geographic boundary. For residents, businesses, and industrial units situated in the two districts, the regulatory order creates no immediate requirement to modify their existing utility arrangements. The incumbent government discom will continue normal power supply operations without interruption. Consumers will only gain the practical option to evaluate an alternative service provider once the private company completes construction of its network and physically reaches specific neighbourhoods or industrial clusters. Political Criticism And Concerns Over Public Utilities The regulatory ruling has sparked strong criticism from political figures across the state. Indian National Lok Dal patron and former Minister Sampat Singh came out strongly against the decision, warning of severe long-term consequences for the state's power ecosystem. Singh argued that granting a parallel distribution licence to Eleven Power for Gurugram and Nuh was far from an ordinary regulatory order. In a formal statement, Singh described the regulatory action as an unprecedented disruption to Haryana's power distribution framework, asserting that for the first time two separate distribution agencies are being permitted to operate concurrently within the same territory. Historically, electrical distribution in any designated region within Haryana has been administered exclusively by either a state public sector utility or a single private licensee, rather than two concurrent agencies competing inside the same supply boundary. Revenue Implications And The Impending Legal Dispute Singh also raised questions regarding the state government's conduct, asserting that the administration's actions suggested the outcome was not solely an independent regulatory determination. He drew attention to the financial structure of the public utility, emphasizing that Gurugram generates a disproportionately large share of total revenue for Dakshin Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam. Furthermore, Gurugram consistently records among the lowest aggregate technical and commercial distribution losses across the entire discom territory. The concentration of lucrative, high-tariff commercial and industrial consumers in Gurugram enables public utilities to maintain cross-subsidies that support affordable tariffs for agricultural tube-wells, rural households, and underprivileged consumers. The prospect of an alternative distributor competing for premium consumers threatens the revenue balance that sustains the broader public power infrastructure. With the state government preparing to lodge its appeal before the Appellate Tribunal for Electricity, the regulatory order faces intensive judicial scrutiny. While Eleven Power continues to cite its five-year investment schedule of Rs 4,717 crore toward a 2027-28 launch, Dakshin Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam remains the sole active distributor on the ground as the legal challenge gets underway. What this means for you Consumers in Gurugram and Nuh will see no immediate changes to their electricity connections, though long-term competitive power options may emerge. • Across India: The dispute creates a crucial legal test case for the parallel distribution provisions under Section 14 of the Electricity Act, 2003. A decisive ruling from the tribunal will influence whether other states open lucrative urban distribution zones to concurrent private competitors. • In Haryana: The state government's planned appeal before the appellate tribunal introduces substantial regulatory uncertainty around the private project. Public discom Dakshin Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam will remain the exclusive operational supplier while the legal matter is adjudicated. • For Gurugram and Nuh consumers: Existing power users do not need to make any immediate modifications to their electricity meters or contracts. Switching options will only become accessible if and when the private licensee rolls out physical cabling to their specific localities around 2027-28. • For farmers and rural users: Potential revenue diversion from Gurugram's high-paying commercial consumers could strain the finances of the state discom. Any disruption to the existing cross-subsidy pool could eventually affect concessional tariffs provided to rural households and agricultural consumers. Why this happened The dispute arose after the state electricity regulatory commission granted a 25-year parallel power distribution licence to a private company despite explicit objections from the Haryana government. The state administration views the move as detrimental to the financial stability of its public distribution utility. • The immediate trigger: The Haryana Electricity Regulatory Commission issued an order dated October 19 granting Eleven Power Private Limited a parallel distribution licence for Gurugram and Nuh. Energy Minister Anil Vij stated that the administration opposed the move on every regulatory point, prompting the decision to appeal. • Legal framework enabling the order: Section 14 of the Electricity Act, 2003 permits regulatory commissions to authorise more than one electricity distributor within the same area of supply. The private applicant applied directly to the autonomous regulatory body under this statutory provision rather than approaching the state government. • Discom revenue vulnerability: Gurugram accounts for a disproportionate share of total revenue for Dakshin Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam while maintaining very low technical and commercial losses. Critics argue that parallel licensing allows private firms to cherry-pick lucrative consumers, leaving the state utility with subsidised rural and agricultural loads. • Next steps in the dispute: The state government will lodge a formal appeal with the Appellate Tribunal for Electricity seeking to challenge or overturn the licence. The trajectory of Eleven Power's planned Rs 4,717 crore investment and its 2027-28 operational target will depend entirely on the tribunal's verdict. Questions & Answers 1. Why is the Haryana government appealing before APTEL? The state government is challenging the regulatory commission's order that granted a parallel electricity distribution licence to Eleven Power Private Limited for Gurugram and Nuh. 2. What is the duration of the licence granted to Eleven Power? The Haryana Electricity Regulatory Commission granted the parallel electricity distribution licence for a tenure of 25 years under an order dated October 19. 3. How much capital does Eleven Power plan to invest in the project? The company plans to invest Rs 4,717 crore over five years, with commercial electricity supply projected to commence in the 2027-28 fiscal year. 4. Will the new licence replace the existing state utility DHBVN? No, Dakshin Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam will continue supplying electricity, as parallel licensing allows two operators to function in the same geographic territory. 5. Do consumers in Gurugram and Nuh need to take any immediate action? No, existing consumers require no immediate steps, and the option to switch will only open once the private network reaches their specific area. 6. What concerns were raised by former Minister Sampat Singh? He warned that the decision harms the public power sector and rural consumers, noting that Gurugram generates a disproportionately high share of DHBVN's revenue. https://trendkia.com/en/business/gurugram-aura-nuh-men-niji-bijali-vitarana-ke-phaisale-ko-chunauti-degi-haryana-sarakara-aptel-men-apila-ki-taiyari-49542 TrendKia — Har trend, sabse pehle.