# Questions Raised Over Free 20 Crore Land Gift to Yusuf Pathan in Vadodara

> The Vadodara Municipal Corporation has approved a proposal to gift a disputed plot of land to former cricketer and MP Yusuf Pathan, sparking intense debate over its legality.

**Type:** article · **Category:** Cricket · **Published:** 2026-10-25 · **Source:** TrendKia
**Canonical:** https://trendkia.com/en/cricket/vadodara-mein-yusuf-pathan-ko-20-crore-ki-zameen-muft-dene-par-uthe-sawal-kya-kehta-hai-kanoon-51516 · **Language:** English
**Tags:** Yusuf Pathan, Vadodara Municipal Corporation, land allocation, Gujarat government, legal controversy

Former cricketer and MP Yusuf Pathan, who had been fighting with the municipal authorities for a 978-square-meter plot in Vadodara for the past 14 years, is now set to receive the land as a gift from the Vadodara Municipal Corporation (VMC). This is the exact plot for which the civic body had issued a notice to Pathan two years ago on charges of encroachment. However, on Friday evening, October 23, the standing committee of the Vadodara Municipal Corporation approved this proposal. All 12 members of this standing committee are BJP corporators. The decision will now be presented before the general board of the municipal corporation for final ratification. While the controversy surrounding the land allocation to Yusuf Pathan has already begun, the core question remains: what is the legal basis for allocating land in this manner, what are the conditions attached, and has anyone else ever been given land in this fashion or is this an isolated case?

## What is the Municipal Corporation Proposal?
According to reports, this proposal pertains to 978 square meters of land located in Vadodara Town Planning Scheme 22, Final Plot 90, which sits directly adjacent to Yusuf Pathan's bungalow. The total market value of this 978-square-meter plot is approximately Rs 20.53 crore. Under the proposal, the municipal corporation will grant 500 square meters of this land to him entirely free of cost as a gift, valued at around Rs 15 crore. The remaining 478 square meters of land is being offered to him at a concessional rate, meaning Yusuf Pathan will only have to pay 55 percent of the fixed price, amounting to roughly Rs 5.52 crore, for the remaining portion. This translates to 500 square meters for free and the remaining 478 square meters at nearly half price. The municipal corporation has explicitly stated in the land allocation proposal that this is an exception and cannot be used as a precedent in the future.

## Can Government Land be Given as a Gift?
The Gujarat government framed specific rules on September 17, 2002, for allocating government land and other properties, known as the Urban and Regional Development Authorities (Allotment of Land and Other Properties) Rules, 2002. Rule 3(1) of these regulations outlines the permissible methods through which an authority can grant land or plots. According to this rule, the authority may sell land or properties, lease them out for a maximum period of 99 years, or confer development rights to someone, all while adhering to established regulations and guidelines. Thus, the rules prescribe three distinct methods for land disposal: outright sale, lease for up to 99 years, and granting development rights.

## Provisions for Sale and Auction
Reports citing government officials indicate that following amendments to the rules, land is now typically allotted through sale rather than 99-year leases. Furthermore, Rule 3(2) specifies how government land can be allocated, which includes public auctions, inviting tenders from companies or individuals through public advertisements, or allocating land to governmental and public institutions in certain cases. Additionally, applications can be invited from the public by issuing formal advertisements. However, none of these provisions include granting government land to an individual free of cost or as a gift.

## A Special Case Without Precedent
The rules contain no provision allowing government land to be presented to any individual as a gift. Officials explain that this is precisely why the decision to gift land to Yusuf Pathan is being treated as a special case, and cannot be used as a precedent for future matters. According to the authorities, the state government has exercised its special powers to arrive at this decision, which allows the government to exercise its discretion under exceptional circumstances. The Vadodara Municipal Corporation has cited Rule 13 to justify its decision, which permits land allocation proposals for institutions, charitable trusts, schools, colleges, research institutes, societies, and religious trusts, provided the land is used for public welfare. However, Rule 13 contains no provision for gifting land to an individual sportsperson. Officials note that this is the first instance of its kind in the history of the Vadodara Municipal Corporation, as no individual has ever been gifted a plot by the civic body before, giving rise to persistent legal questions surrounding the allotment.

## What this means for you
The decision by the Vadodara Municipal Corporation to grant crores worth of land for free and at concessional rates to former cricketer Yusuf Pathan has triggered a serious debate on administrative transparency and the use of public assets at the local level.

- **In Vadodara:** Local citizens and taxpayers are actively questioning whether such special exceptions and relaxations could ever be extended to ordinary citizens. The decision has raised local concerns regarding municipal governance and the influence of prominent figures.
- **Across India:** This case prompts renewed scrutiny over the allocation of government lands and the strict enforcement of regulations across urban civic bodies nationwide. It fuels a broader national discussion regarding the privileges extended to politicians and celebrities.

## Why this happened
This entire development is the result of a land dispute spanning the last 14 years and specific decisions taken at political and administrative levels. The Vadodara Municipal Corporation and the state government took this extraordinary step by exercising their discretionary powers.

- **Land Dispute:** Yusuf Pathan had been attempting to acquire this 978-square-meter plot located adjacent to his bungalow in Vadodara's town planning area for the past 14 years.
- **Administrative Notice:** Sometime ago, the municipal corporation had also issued a notice to Pathan alleging encroachment on this very plot, which brought the matter into intense public focus.
- **Exercise of Special Powers:** Since the regulations do not contain a direct provision to gift land to an individual, the state government invoked its special discretionary powers to push the proposal forward.
- **Local Committee Approval:** The standing committee of the Vadodara Municipal Corporation passed this proposal with the unanimous consent of all its members, and it is now slated to be presented to the general board for final ratification.

## Questions & Answers

### 1. How much land is being given to Yusuf Pathan in Vadodara?
A total of 978 square meters of land is being allotted to Yusuf Pathan by the Vadodara Municipal Corporation.

### 2. How much of this land is being given for free as a gift?
Out of this, 500 square meters of land is being given to Yusuf Pathan entirely free of cost as a gift.

### 3. How much payment is required for the remaining land?
For the remaining 478 square meters of land, he will have to pay 55 percent of the fixed price, amounting to approximately Rs 5.52 crore.

### 4. Who has approved this proposal?
The standing committee of the Vadodara Municipal Corporation approved this proposal on October 23.

### 5. Do the rules contain any provision to gift land to an individual?
Existing regulations do not contain any provision allowing government land to be gifted to an individual.

---
_TrendKia — Har trend, sabse pehle.. Machine-readable view; canonical HTML at the URL above._