Bombay High Court Rules Public Restrooms Near Monuments Are Permissible The Aurangabad bench of the Bombay High Court has ruled that constructing public toilets within the vicinity of protected monuments does not violate heritage laws, quashing a state archaeology department notice. Striking a balance between the preservation of historical landmarks and the basic necessities of the general public, the Bombay High Court has delivered a significant ruling. The court clarified that building public restrooms in the vicinity of protected monuments does not fall under the category of restricted construction activities. Denying visitors basic sanitation facilities under the guise of heritage conservation runs contrary to the best interests of the monument and its surrounding area. The Aurangabad bench of the Bombay High Court pronounced this verdict in a case concerning the construction of a public toilet near the Dargah Hazrat Syed Shah Raju Kattal Hussaini in Khuldabad, located in the Chhatrapati Sambhajinagar district of Maharashtra. Accepting the appeal filed by the mutawalli of the dargah, the bench set aside the stop-work notice issued by the state archaeology department in the year 2018. The Khuldabad Municipal Council had strongly supported the petition filed by the mutawalli. To curb the problem of open defecation, the civic body initiated the sanitation project utilizing funds provided by the Maharashtra government under the Swachh Bharat Abhiyan and the recommendations of the 14th Finance Commission. The restroom was being built outside the boundary walls of the shrine but well within a 100-meter radius. Meanwhile, the state government issued stop-work notices in October and November 2018, arguing that under the Maharashtra Ancient Monuments and Archaeological Sites and Remains Act, prior permission was mandatory for any construction work within 100 meters of a protected monument. Citing the central Ancient Monuments and Archaeological Sites and Remains Act, the petitioner and the municipal council argued that the definition of construction near protected monuments should not encompass public toilets, urinals, drainage systems, and similar essential public utilities. Taking into account public convenience and the hardships faced by thousands of devotees who arrive from various states during the annual Urs, the High Court noted that depriving visitors of sanitation facilities would ultimately harm the monument and its surroundings rather than protect them. The court observed that failing to provide such civic amenities near the monument would not serve its interests, as the thousands of tourists visiting the site would be left without restroom access, thereby damaging the landmark and the adjacent locality instead of securing it. While quashing the stop-work order, the bench directed the assistant director of the archaeology department in Aurangabad to decide on the pending approval application from December 2018 within two weeks, after hearing both the dargah custodian and the municipal council. The court also granted the parties the option to mutually select an alternative site acceptable to both sides. What this means for you This ruling carries significant practical implications for visitors and local authorities managing public infrastructure near historical sites. • In Maharashtra: Civic bodies gain legal clarity to build essential sanitation infrastructure like public restrooms near protected heritage sites without facing arbitrary department blocks. • Across India: The judgment establishes a balanced legal precedent ensuring that heritage conservation laws do not override basic public hygiene and commuter necessities. Why this happened The dispute arose from a clash between state heritage regulations and local civic requirements for basic sanitation facilities. • Work Stoppage: The state archaeology department halted construction, arguing that prior permissions were mandatory under monuments protection acts for work within a 100-meter radius. • Public Necessity: The municipal council maintained that building restrooms was vital to prevent open defecation and accommodate thousands of pilgrims attending the annual Urs. Questions & Answers 1. What did the Bombay High Court rule regarding the construction? The High Court ruled that building public restrooms near protected monuments is permissible and quashed the stop-work notice. 2. Which district is this case associated with? The case is associated with Khuldabad in the Chhatrapati Sambhajinagar district of Maharashtra. 3. Why did the archaeology department halt the construction? The department argued that prior permission was not obtained for construction within a 100-meter radius of the protected monument. 4. What directions did the court issue to the authorities? The court directed the archaeology department to decide on the pending approval application within two weeks after hearing all parties. https://trendkia.com/en/maharashtra/bombay-high-court-rules-public-restrooms-near-monuments-are-permissible-60757 TrendKia — Har trend, sabse pehle.