# Supreme Court Declines to Merge Cyber Fraud FIRs Across States and Rejects Any Leniency for Scammers

> The Supreme Court dismissed a plea seeking the consolidation of cyber fraud FIRs registered across Gujarat and Haryana, ruling that an accused cannot dictate where victims file their complaints.

**Type:** article · **Category:** India · **Published:** 2026-11-20 · **Source:** TrendKia
**Canonical:** https://trendkia.com/en/national/saibara-dhokhadhari-ke-mamalon-ko-rajyon-ke-bicha-jorane-se-supreme-court-ka-inakara-kaha-thagon-ko-nahin-mila-sakati-koi-dhila-61533 · **Language:** English
**Tags:** Supreme Court, Cyber Fraud, FIR, Surya Kant, Gujarat, Haryana

The Supreme Court has rejected a petition seeking the consolidation of first information reports (FIRs) registered in two different states regarding an alleged cyber scam, ruling that an accused person cannot decide where victims ought to lodge their grievances. A three-judge bench firmly turned down requests for judicial leniency, reiterating that statutory criminal procedure must be enforced strictly against organised digital offences.

## Allegations of Investment Fraud Involving Virtual Cloud Space
The proceedings stem from an alleged investment scam involving the purported sale of virtual cloud space. The petitioner, Bhumi Utpalbhai Patel, approached the apex court seeking an order to club the criminal cases registered against him across the states of Gujarat and Haryana into a single proceeding. The plea rested on the claim that multiple concurrent inquiries across state lines create procedural overlaps, but the court found no merit in using that logic to shield the accused from distinct jurisdictional investigations.

## Three-Judge Bench Denies Relief and Emphasises Full Rigour of the Law
The matter was heard by a bench comprising Chief Justice Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi, and Justice V. Mohana. During the hearing, the bench observed that common elements or similarities across police investigations cannot serve as a valid legal ground to confer advantages upon an accused person. Justice Bagchi highlighted that an accused cannot restrain police forces from different states from conducting their respective inquiries, clarifying that decisions regarding the direction of an investigation fall squarely within the mandate of investigative agencies.

When the defence counsel pleaded for a more lenient approach, the court refused to dilute its position. Justice Bagchi observed, **“No concession. The law should be applied with full rigour in such cases.”** The bench noted that preserving the full force of criminal law is essential when dealing with networks engaged in structured digital and cyber fraud.

## Jurisdictional Proceedings and the Limited Recourse Left Open
Criminal proceedings against the petitioner remain pending before trial courts in two different regions, namely Gandhinagar in Gujarat and Faridabad in Haryana. According to official records placed before the Supreme Court, the petitioner had previously surrendered, and a custody certificate confirming his detention was formally submitted. He has been lodged as an undertrial prisoner inside Ahmedabad Central Jail in Gujarat for a duration of 5 months and 5 days.

While declining to merge FIRs across two separate states, the apex court preserved one specific avenue of procedural relief. The bench stated that the petitioner remains free to approach the concerned High Court if he seeks the consolidation of multiple criminal proceedings that have been registered strictly within the boundaries of a single state.

## What this means for you
This ruling reinforces the rights of cyber fraud victims across India and restricts accused individuals from seeking procedural shortcuts across state borders.

- **Rights of Victims:** Victims nationwide maintain the full legal discretion to register complaints in their local jurisdictions. Accused persons cannot force victims to coordinate or transfer their grievances to another state.
- **Investigative Independence:** Police agencies in different states retain the complete authority to independently pursue their inquiries. A parallel probe in one state cannot be cited as a reason to stay or merge proceedings in another.
- **Strict Legal Consequences:** Individuals facing allegations of organised cyber scams will not receive procedural leniency from the judiciary. Accused persons must answer charges separately before every trial court where offences are registered.
- **Procedural Pathways:** Litigants seeking the clubbing of FIRs within a single state must approach the respective High Court rather than directly approaching the apex court. This maintains the jurisdictional hierarchy of state-level courts for intra-state matters.

## Why this happened
This decision occurred because the petitioner sought to merge criminal cases pending in different states, which the court deemed contrary to victim rights and investigative autonomy.

- **Petitioner's Legal Plea:** The accused, Bhumi Utpalbhai Patel, requested the consolidation of cases in Gujarat and Haryana arguing that the investigations shared factual similarities. The bench ruled that investigational commonalities cannot be used to confer legal benefits upon an accused.
- **Protection of Victim Choice:** The apex court affirmed that victims hold the procedural prerogative to lodge complaints where the harm occurred. An accused person cannot dictate or restrict the forum chosen by those seeking justice.
- **State Police Jurisdiction:** The judges noted that police forces in respective states have independent statutory obligations to investigate offences committed within their boundaries. An accused cannot legally bar state authorities from carrying out separate investigations.

## Questions & Answers

### 1. Which states were involved in the FIR clubbing plea before the Supreme Court?
The plea sought to consolidate first information reports registered in Gujarat and Haryana.

### 2. What is the nature of the alleged offence in this case?
The case involves an alleged investment fraud related to the sale of virtual cloud space.

### 3. Who is the petitioner and how long has he been in custody?
The petitioner is Bhumi Utpalbhai Patel, who has been held in Ahmedabad Central Jail for 5 months and 5 days.

### 4. Who were the judges on the three-judge bench hearing the petition?
The bench comprised Chief Justice Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi, and Justice V. Mohana.

### 5. What legal recourse did the Supreme Court leave open for the petitioner?
The court stated that the petitioner can approach the concerned High Court to seek the clubbing of cases registered within a single state.

---
_TrendKia — Har trend, sabse pehle.. Machine-readable view; canonical HTML at the URL above._