# Supreme Court denies Prashant Bhushan plea, CJI Surya Kant rejects separate listing for election commissioners appointment case

> The Supreme Court has rejected senior advocate Prashant Bhushan's request to separately list a review petition concerning the appointment of election commissioners. CJI Surya Kant stated that the matter must be addressed by the already constituted five-judge constitution bench.

**Type:** article · **Category:** India · **Published:** 2026-11-20 · **Source:** TrendKia
**Canonical:** https://trendkia.com/en/national/supreme-court-denies-prashant-bhushan-plea-cji-surya-kant-rejects-separate-listing-for-election-commissioners-appointment-case-61469 · **Language:** English
**Tags:** Prashant Bhushan, Supreme Court, CJI Surya Kant, Election Commissioners, legal news

The apex court has dealt a setback to senior lawyer Prashant Bhushan by declining a procedural request regarding a high-profile electoral appointment dispute. Chief Justice Surya Kant turned down the plea to list a review application before a separate bench of judges.

 

## Matter to be Heard by Constitution Bench

The court clarified that any challenge to the existing framework must be brought before the five-judge constitution bench that was previously established to examine the case. The bench previously comprising Justice Dipankar Datta and Justice Satish Chandra Sharma will not take up this specific listing request.

 

## Recall Applications Remain Valid

Addressing procedural longevity, the Chief Justice noted that even if a presiding judge retires, the designated five-judge bench retains the authority to evaluate any pending recall applications. The latest ruling maintains the established judicial channel for handling challenges related to the appointment mechanism of election commissioners.

## What this means for you
This judicial decision sets a clear precedent for how high-level institutional appointment challenges and review petitions are processed in the highest court.

- **Across India:** The ruling reinforces that complex constitutional matters must follow established judicial channels rather than expedited individual listings.
- **In Legal Proceedings:** It ensures that benches constituted for specific landmark issues retain jurisdiction over subsequent review applications.

## Why this happened
This development stems from recent legal challenges and review petitions filed by advocates seeking modifications or fresh hearings on the oversight mechanisms governing election commissioner appointments.

- **Procedural Rules:** The court emphasized adherence to established institutional pathways rather than allowing separate listings for matters already assigned to larger benches.
- **Bench Jurisdiction:** The existing five-judge constitution bench retains the primary authority to evaluate the underlying reference orders and recall pleas.

## Questions & Answers

### 1. What request did Prashant Bhushan make in the Supreme Court?
Prashant Bhushan requested a separate listing for a review petition concerning the appointment of election commissioners.

### 2. Who rejected the listing request?
Chief Justice Surya Kant rejected the plea to list the matter separately.

### 3. Where will the matter now be heard?
The matter is designated to be heard before the already established five-judge constitution bench.

### 4. Can the bench consider applications if a judge retires?
The CJI stated that the five-judge bench can consider recall applications even after a judge retires.

---
_TrendKia — Har trend, sabse pehle.. Machine-readable view; canonical HTML at the URL above._