{
  "type": "article",
  "title": "Punjab Assembly Sees Stormy Debates Over BJP MLA Ashwani Sharma Analogy On State Blame Game",
  "summary": "BJP MLA Ashwani Sharma sparked a major row in the Punjab Assembly during discussions on calling attention motions after using a controversial childbirth analogy to criticize the governing party's habit of blaming the Centre.",
  "content": "The fourth day of the monsoon session in the Punjab Legislative Assembly witnessed heated exchanges on Thursday after Bharatiya Janata Party lawmaker Ashwani Sharma delivered a controversial remark while targeting the governing party. Speaking during the proceedings in Chandigarh, the former state party president accused the administration of routinely deflecting responsibility for local administrative failures onto the Central government, using an unconventional comparison that drew immediate protests from the treasury benches.\n\nControversial Remarks During Call-Attention Motions\nThe commotion erupted while the House was holding deliberations on calling attention motions. Addressing the assembly, Ashwani Sharma claimed that the ruling party takes sole credit whenever positive developments occur in the state but shifts the blame to New Delhi whenever challenges arise. Framing his argument with an apology in advance, he remarked that if a boy is born, the administration claims credit for hard work, whereas if a girl is born, they accuse the Centre of being at fault. The phrasing was instantly met with fierce objections from members of the ruling party.\n\nScrutiny Over Illegal Mining and Sand Policy\nBeyond his analogy, Ashwani Sharma directed sharp criticism toward the state's ongoing handling of illegal sand mining operations. He called for a thorough review of the ground reality surrounding the government policy known as Jisda Khet, Usdi Ret, which was designed to grant land owners rights over the sand on their property. Sharma asserted that the policy remains ineffective on the ground and alleged that senior leaders from the ruling party regularly intimidate and threaten individuals who attempt to raise their voices against illegal mining activities in their local areas.\n\nTreasury Bench Demands Apology Over Remarks\nThe comments provoked strong indignation from lawmakers of the ruling party, who categorized the lawmaker's analogy as deeply insensitive and derogatory toward women. Assembly members immediately disrupted proceedings to condemn the language used on the House floor, surrounding the issue with vocal protests and demanding an unconditional apology from the BJP legislator for disparaging female children in his political critique.\n\nClarification and Counter-Attack by Ashwani Sharma\nResponding to the backlash, Ashwani Sharma offered a clarification regarding his statement, explaining that he had merely quoted an old popular proverb to illustrate his political point about accountability. He stated that if the Assembly Speaker deemed the phrase unparliamentary, it should be expunged from the official records of the House. Expressing regret if his words had hurt anyone's sentiments, Sharma subsequently launched a counter-attack against the governing party. He questioned the ruling party's commitment to women's dignity, asking where their outrage was when female protesters were subjected to a police lathi-charge during a previous demonstration in Barnala.\n\nWhat this means for you\n• Across India: It raises public awareness and discourse regarding parliamentary decorum and the language used in political debates.\n• In Punjab: It highlights ongoing administrative scrutiny over local issues such as illegal sand mining and the implementation of state mining policies.\n\nQuestions & Answers\n\n1. What caused the ruckus in the Punjab Assembly?\nBJP MLA Ashwani Sharma used a controversial childbirth analogy to criticize the governing party's practice of blaming the Central government for state failures.\n\n2. What did Ashwani Sharma say about illegal mining?\nHe questioned the ground reality of the 'Jisda Khet, Usdi Ret' sand policy and alleged that senior leaders intimidate those who oppose illegal mining.\n\n3. How did the ruling party respond to the remarks?\nThe ruling party strongly objected to the comments, calling them derogatory toward women, and demanded an apology from Ashwani Sharma.\n\n4. How did Ashwani Sharma clarify his statement?\nHe stated he was merely using a common proverb as an illustration, offered to have it expunged if deemed unparliamentary, and expressed regret if sentiments were hurt.\n\n5. What counter-question did Ashwani Sharma raise?\nHe questioned the ruling party's stance by asking where their concern was when female protesters faced a police lathi-charge in Barnala.",
  "url": "https://trendkia.com/en/politics/punjab-assembly-men-bjp-mla-ashwani-sharma-ke-bayana-para-bhari-hngama-aap-ne-jataya-kara-virodha-14605",
  "category": "Politics",
  "publishedAt": "2026-08-07",
  "tags": [
    "Punjab Assembly",
    "Ashwani Sharma",
    "BJP",
    "AAP",
    "Illegal Mining",
    "Barnala"
  ],
  "language": "en",
  "site": "TrendKia"
}