Punjab Cabinet Clashes With Centre Just Hours Before Justice Ashwini Mishra's Swearing-In

Punjab's cabinet has objected to the Centre's appointment of Justice Ashwini Kumar Mishra as Chief Justice of the Punjab and Haryana High Court, urging the Governor to hold off his swearing-in. Chief Minister Bhagwant Mann accused the Centre of bypassing constitutional procedure without consulting the state government.

A fresh standoff has broken out between the Punjab government and the Centre just hours before Justice Ashwini Kumar Mishra was due to be sworn in as the new Chief Justice of the Punjab and Haryana High Court in Chandigarh. On Sunday evening, the Punjab cabinet called an emergency meeting and passed a resolution against the Centre's decision, asking the Governor to hold off both the appointment and the swearing-in ceremony until the state government's opinion is sought and properly considered. The cabinet said the entire decision had been taken by bypassing constitutional rules and established procedures.

Mann accuses the Centre of ignoring constitutional process
Chief Minister Bhagwant Mann has levelled a serious charge against the Centre, accusing it of directly encroaching on Punjab's rights and repeatedly violating constitutional rules. In a post on the social media platform X, Mann said the new Chief Justice of the Punjab and Haryana High Court had been appointed without the state government's consent. He called it a direct violation of the Memorandum of Procedure and of constitutional norms governing such appointments. The Chief Minister has been clear that appointing a High Court Chief Justice without taking the state government into confidence amounts to direct interference by the Centre in the functioning of the judiciary, and weakens the state's constitutional role in the process.

 

What the cabinet resolution demands
The Punjab government has demanded that the appointment be halted immediately and that the state's opinion be respected in line with constitutional procedure. The cabinet's resolution specifically asks the Centre not to administer the oath of office to Justice Ashwini Kumar Mishra as Chief Justice of the Punjab and Haryana High Court until Punjab's consent is obtained. The official statement issued after the cabinet meeting said the Centre had bypassed the state's constitutional rights and long-established procedures, and the cabinet strongly condemned this in the statement.

Notification came Saturday, oath was set for Monday
The Centre issued the official notification of Justice Mishra's appointment on Saturday. The Supreme Court collegium had recommended his elevation roughly a month earlier. Justice Ashwini Kumar Mishra has been serving as acting Chief Justice of the Punjab and Haryana High Court since June, and the Governor was scheduled to administer him the oath of office as Chief Justice on Monday. Just hours before that swearing-in ceremony, the Mann government convened an emergency cabinet meeting over video conferencing to oppose the Centre's decision, and it was at this meeting that the resolution was passed.

What happens next
It remains unclear whether the Centre will accept the Punjab cabinet's demand or whether the Governor will go ahead and administer the oath to Justice Mishra on Monday as originally scheduled. Punjab's position is that it will not accept the appointment until its opinion is factored in, while the Centre has not yet issued any public response to the cabinet's resolution.

What this means for you
If the standoff between the Centre and the Punjab government drags on, it could affect the administrative functioning of the Punjab and Haryana High Court and the pace at which pending cases are heard.

• Across India: The dispute could reopen a wider debate on how much say state governments should have in constitutional appointments like a High Court Chief Justice, and other states may take a firmer stance on similar appointments going forward.
• In Punjab and Haryana: If the swearing-in is delayed, uncertainty over who leads the High Court will persist, which could slow down the disposal of pending cases. Administrative decisions at the Chandigarh-based High Court may also get caught up in this political standoff.
• For lawyers and litigants: A delay in the Chief Justice's appointment could hold up administrative processes such as the formation of benches and listing of cases, affecting lawyers and litigants already waiting on pending matters.

Questions & Answers

1. Who is Justice Ashwini Kumar Mishra?
He has been serving as acting Chief Justice of the Punjab and Haryana High Court since June, and the Centre has now appointed him as the permanent Chief Justice.

2. What is Punjab's objection?
The Punjab government says the appointment was made without seeking the state government's opinion and by bypassing the established constitutional procedure.

3. What has the Punjab cabinet demanded?
The cabinet has asked the Governor not to administer the oath to Justice Mishra until the Punjab government's consent is obtained.

4. When was the swearing-in ceremony scheduled?
The Governor was scheduled to administer the oath of office to Justice Mishra as Chief Justice on Monday.

5. What did Chief Minister Bhagwant Mann allege?
He accused the Centre of encroaching on Punjab's rights and violating the Memorandum of Procedure and constitutional rules.

6. Who recommended the appointment?
The Supreme Court collegium had recommended Justice Mishra's elevation roughly a month earlier.

7. When did the Centre issue the appointment notification?
The Centre issued the official notification of Justice Mishra's appointment on Saturday.

https://trendkia.com/en/punjab/jastisa-ashwini-kumar-mishra-ki-shapatha-se-thika-pahale-punjab-kaibineta-ka-kendra-sarakara-para-tikha-hamala-28684
TrendKia — Har trend, sabse pehle.