# Judicial Commission Blames SP MP For Sambhal Mosque Violence, Details Massive Demographic Shift

> The judicial commission investigating the Sambhal Jama Masjid survey violence has presented its 450-page report to the UP cabinet. The exhaustive document blames SP MP Zia-ur-Rehman Barq's statements for the unrest while detailing drastic demographic shifts and an 83-year history of local communal riots.

**Type:** article · **Category:** Uttar Pradesh · **Published:** 2026-07-22 · **Source:** TrendKia
**Canonical:** https://trendkia.com/en/uttar-pradesh/sambhal-hinsa-para-nyayika-ayoga-ka-bara-khulasa-sp-sansada-ka-bayana-bana-bavala-ki-jara-9715 · **Language:** English
**Tags:** Sambhal Violence, Jama Masjid Dispute, UP Government, Zia-ur-Rehman Barq, Uttar Pradesh Assembly

A comprehensive judicial commission report investigating the violent clashes that erupted during the Shahi Jama Masjid survey in Sambhal on November 24, 2024, has been officially presented to the Uttar Pradesh state cabinet. The exhaustive document, spanning approximately 450 pages, delves deeply into the root causes of the unrest, the shifting social dynamics of the region, and the historical context of communal tensions. Having been submitted to Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath in August of the previous year, the findings are now scheduled to be tabled on the floor of the legislative assembly during its upcoming monsoon session. The highly anticipated report brings forth several serious claims regarding political provocation, demographic changes, and foreign criminal links.

## Political Provocation and Community Clashes
According to the detailed findings, the immediate catalyst for the November violence was a public statement made by Samajwadi Party Member of Parliament Zia-ur-Rehman Barq. The commission noted that his remarks, delivered just two days prior on November 22, 2024, severely disrupted the local atmosphere. The parliamentarian had reportedly stated that his community were the owners of the country rather than servants or slaves. The investigative body concluded that these specific words rapidly escalated hostilities. Interestingly, the report highlights that the resulting tension was not primarily communal in the traditional sense, but rather exacerbated a bitter rivalry for dominance between the local Pathan and Turk communities. The subsequent gunfire and street battles tragically claimed the lives of four individuals.

## Drastic Demographic Shifts
Beyond the immediate triggers of the recent unrest, the commission dedicated a significant portion of its 450-page review to analyzing the changing population demographics of the Sambhal municipal area. The findings suggest a massive transformation over the past several decades. At the time of India's independence, the Hindu population in the city stood at roughly 45 percent. Today, that figure has plummeted to a mere 15 percent. The judicial panel attributed this steep decline to a sustained pattern of localized riots, targeted violence, religious conversions, and forced displacement over a prolonged period. The report explicitly outlines a phased evolution of the local conflict dynamics based on these population numbers.

## Phases of Local Conflict
The investigators mapped out a clear pattern in how violence has manifested in the city. The report asserts that as long as the Hindu population remained above the 40 percent mark, they were the primary targets of organized riots, religious conversions, and related incidents. However, as the demographic balance shifted and the Hindu population dropped below the critical 20 percent threshold, the nature of the local conflicts changed entirely. The vacuum of dominance led to an intense and ongoing turf war between the Pathan and Turk factions. This internal supremacy battle has reportedly kept the city on edge for an extended period, creating a volatile environment where any spark could lead to widespread violence.

## Eight Decades of Historical Violence
To provide a broader context, the judicial commission meticulously documented the history of riots in the region spanning from 1936 to 2019. The official records incorporated into the report detail 15 major communal riots during this 83-year timeframe. The human cost of these disturbances has been staggering, with a total of 213 recorded fatalities. The demographic breakdown of the victims presented in the document is particularly stark. Out of the 213 people who lost their lives in these 15 historical riots, 209 were identified as Hindus. Conversely, the official toll lists only four Muslim fatalities across the same period, with two deaths occurring in 1992 and another two during incidents in 2019. The report specifically highlights a horrific episode of violence that took place following the Holi festival on March 29, 1978, which alone accounted for the deaths of 184 Hindus.

## Encroachment on Sacred Sites and Foreign Links
The exhaustive investigation also addressed the systematic encroachment upon religious and historical landmarks within the city. The panel identified 68 specific pilgrimage sites and 19 sacred wells that have been gradually occupied and built upon over the years. Furthermore, the inquiry took a severe view of the criminal elements involved in the recent violence, pointing towards dangerous cross-border connections. The document explicitly names local gangster Shariq Satha, alleging that he maintained active ties with a counterfeit currency syndicate run by Pakistan's intelligence agency. Adding weight to the claims of external involvement, the report noted that the weapons recovered by the police during the post-violence crackdown included a foreign-made pistol distinctly engraved with a 'Made in USA' mark.

## Broader Security Implications
The uncovering of a foreign firearm and established connections to Pakistani intelligence networks elevate this incident from a localized law and order problem to a matter of national security. Authorities are now tasked with unraveling the supply chains that allowed sophisticated foreign weapons to enter the district and fall into the hands of rioters. Furthermore, the systematic encroachment on 68 religious sites and 19 historical wells raises serious questions about the administrative oversight in the region over the past several decades. As the Uttar Pradesh government prepares to formally present these 450 pages to the legislative assembly, political analysts anticipate a fiery session. The opposition is expected to heavily scrutinize the commission's methodology, particularly regarding historical riot data from 1936 onwards, while the ruling party will likely use the findings to justify stricter law enforcement protocols in communally sensitive zones.

## What this means for you
- **Across India:** The revelation of foreign weaponry and intelligence links serves as a severe warning for national security agencies, likely prompting stricter surveillance and border checks nationwide.
- **In Uttar Pradesh:** The tabling of this report in the state assembly could lead to heightened security deployments in Sambhal and surrounding districts, potentially affecting daily commutes and internet services for local residents.

## Questions & Answers

### 1. What is in the judicial commission report on the Sambhal violence?
The 450-page report documents the causes of the November 24, 2024 violence, demographic shifts, and a detailed history of past riots in the city.

### 2. What was identified as the main cause of the recent unrest?
According to the findings, a statement made by Samajwadi Party MP Zia-ur-Rehman Barq on November 22, 2024, was the primary trigger for the violence.

### 3. What claim does the report make about Sambhal's population?
The investigation asserts that the Hindu population in the city was 45 percent at the time of independence but has now dropped to just 15 percent.

### 4. How many riots occurred in Sambhal between 1936 and 2019?
According to the commission's data, the city witnessed 15 major communal riots during this period, resulting in a total of 213 deaths.

### 5. What was revealed regarding foreign weapons?
Among the weapons recovered by the police following the violence was a foreign-made pistol specifically engraved with a 'Made in USA' mark.

### 6. Where will the judicial commission's report be presented next?
The comprehensive report is scheduled to be tabled on the floor of the Uttar Pradesh legislative assembly during its upcoming monsoon session.

---
_TrendKia — Har trend, sabse pehle.. Machine-readable view; canonical HTML at the URL above._