A federal judge in the United States has acquitted Anton Peraire-Bueno and James Peraire-Bueno, two brothers accused of orchestrating a 25 million dollar exploit across Ethereum's maximal extractable value (MEV) infrastructure. US District Judge Clarke ruled that federal prosecutors failed to establish that the brothers made the material false representations required under federal law to sustain wire fraud convictions. The ruling delivered an acquittal on the fraud charges and dismissed the accompanying money laundering conspiracy count, establishing a critical legal precedent for decentralized finance protocols.
The Mechanics of Operation Omakase
The criminal case focused on an incident executed in April 2023, referred to during proceedings as Operation Omakase. Federal prosecutors had alleged that the brothers spent several months meticulously studying the behavioral patterns of automated trading bots that operate on the Ethereum blockchain. These automated bots frequently search for profitable transactions waiting in the mempool to execute sandwich attacks, a practice where a bot buys an asset directly ahead of a large pending transaction and sells it immediately afterward to capture price slippage.
According to prosecutors, the defendants deliberately submitted deceptive bait transactions into the public transaction stream, designed specifically to lead algorithmic trading bots into believing they had discovered highly lucrative sandwich trading opportunities. When the bots responded by submitting transaction bundles backed by millions of dollars in cryptocurrency assets, the brothers allegedly seized on an architectural flaw in MEV-Boost relay software. Within a rapid 12 second window, they accessed the contents of the private transaction bundles and substituted the proposed block data with their own transactions, siphoning 25 million dollars in digital assets while handing catastrophic financial losses to the algorithmic traders.
Why the Court Rejected the Wire Fraud Allegations
To secure a conviction under the federal wire fraud statute, the government must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that a defendant engaged in a scheme to defraud involving material misrepresentations or false statements. Judge Clarke found that the government's arguments fell short of this statutory threshold. The judge ruled that deploying bait transactions across a permissionless blockchain does not constitute an implied promise or contractual guarantee that those transactions will remain open for inclusion in a bot's bundle, nor does it create an obligation to permit oneself to be exploited by a sandwich attack.
The prosecution had also maintained that submitting an invalid block header alongside a cryptographic signature amounted to an actionable false statement designed to trick the relay system. Judge Clarke rejected this premise, noting that the prosecution failed to prove how the contested block header influenced any material judgment or decision by the MEV-Boost relay. The court concluded that registering as an Ethereum validator, requesting an execution payload, and returning a modified block did not represent affirmative legal misrepresentations. In her written assessment, Judge Clarke drew a firm distinction between breaking the operational intent of MEV-Boost software and committing criminal fraud, noting that prosecutors had failed to point to any legally actionable lie.
From Arrest in May 2024 to the 2025 Mistrial
The brothers were formally arrested in May 2024 following an investigation into the high-profile digital asset extraction. The indictment charged Anton and James Peraire-Bueno with conspiracy to commit wire fraud, substantive wire fraud, and conspiracy to commit money laundering. Prosecutors had asserted that the pair engaged in extensive planning and later undertook complex fund routing maneuvers to conceal the nature and ownership of the extracted cryptocurrency.
The criminal trial commenced before a federal jury in Manhattan in October 2025. Jurors heard nearly four weeks of dense, highly technical testimony detailing smart contracts, validator responsibilities, and relay communications. However, the jury reached an irreconcilable deadlock, leading Judge Clarke to formally declare a mistrial on November 7, 2025. Following subsequent post-trial motions and legal analysis, the judge determined that an outright acquittal on the merits was legally required because the government had never established the core element of wire fraud.
Dismissal of the Money Laundering Conspiracy Count
Along with the wire fraud acquittal, Judge Clarke dismissed the government's charge of conspiracy to commit money laundering. Under federal criminal statutes, money laundering requires the underlying funds to represent the proceeds of specific unlawful activity, known as a predicate offense. Because the government failed to establish that the 25 million dollar extraction constituted wire fraud, there was no underlying criminal offense to generate illegal proceeds. Without a valid predicate crime, the money laundering count could not stand.
The ruling represents one of the most substantial legal tests to date regarding the boundaries between code exploitation and federal criminal fraud in the decentralized finance sector. It affirms that while an exploit may violate software design assumptions and inflict severe losses on trading algorithms, the criminal justice system requires specific, provable misrepresentations rather than technical subversion to sustain charges of federal wire fraud.



















