The Supreme Court made a significant observation on Friday regarding the filing of police complaints. The court dismissed a public interest litigation that sought the creation of a separate database for complainants who are frequently accused of lodging repeated sexual offense complaints. During the proceedings, the apex court made it clear that every individual possesses the fundamental right to file a complaint, and a person can even register 100 complaints if necessary. The bench added that if any complaint is found to be false, existing laws already contain adequate provisions to take strict action against the erring person.
The Bench Heard the PIL Against Authorities
The bench comprising Chief Justice Surya Kant, Justice Joymalya Bagchi, and Justice V. Mohana heard the public interest litigation filed by Shauni Kapoor against the central government, the Delhi government, and the Delhi Police Commissioner. Justice Bagchi remarked during the hearing that everyone has the right to file a complaint and can register up to 100 complaints, but if a complaint turns out to be false, the consequences must be faced. The court also expressed serious concern regarding the demand for a database, noting that maintaining such records could pose a severe risk of exposing the identities of victims of sexual offenses.
Court Questions the Need for a Separate Database
During the hearing, the court questioned why there was a need to gather separate identification information when the existing legal framework already contains robust provisions to protect victims' identities and verify complaints. Justice Bagchi stated that the law provides multi-layered safeguards to protect the privacy of victims. He cautioned that compiling a database of complainants by the police could inadvertently lead to the disclosure of their identities.
Meanwhile, the petitioner's counsel argued that the petition requested directions to establish an organized database at every district police headquarters to handle cases involving individuals who allegedly file repetitive complaints. When the court inquired whether the proposed database would include victims or the accused, the lawyer clarified that the database pertained strictly to complainants rather than the accused.
Existing Legal Protections and Investigation Procedures
The counsel submitted that certain individuals misuse the legal process by lodging complaints repeatedly. Questioning the necessity of such a database, Justice Bagchi noted that investigations into sexual offenses already follow established procedures, which include medical examinations and DNA profiling when required. Justice Bagchi highlighted that recording victims' statements before a magistrate is mandatory under the law, providing an additional layer of security to verify complaints. The judge questioned what better identifying data an investigating agency could possibly maintain, following which the bench dismissed the petition.




















