The Supreme Court of India has agreed to examine a petition concerning the serious medical and genetic implications of marriages between close blood relatives, including cousins. A three-judge bench led by Chief Justice Surya Kant, along with Justice Joymalya Bagchi and Justice V. Mohana, issued a notice to the Union Government to explore whether legislative measures or widespread public awareness initiatives are necessary. However, the bench made it explicitly clear that it will not issue any binding directives to the government, reiterating that regulating matrimonial customs remains strictly within the jurisdiction of Parliament and state legislatures.
Plea Highlights Severe Health Risks to Children
The public interest litigation was brought before the apex court by Charvi S., a law student based in Bengaluru. Represented by advocate Anjuman Tripathi, the petition urges the judiciary to review whether existing legal frameworks should continue permitting marital unions that expose future generations to avoidable genetic harm. Medical studies cited during the proceedings indicate that children born to couples with close blood ties face a significantly elevated risk of congenital abnormalities, physical disabilities, mental health disorders, and higher infant mortality rates.
During the hearing, advocate Anjuman Tripathi argued that such marriages remain widely prevalent across various regions, particularly in rural areas where families often lack awareness regarding the underlying genetic hazards. Counsel emphasized that without adequate public education, prospective couples enter into cousin marriages unaware of the potential consequences for their offspring. The petition calls for establishing essential public health safeguards to prevent preventable health complications in newborns.
Petitioner's Personal Background and Legal Arguments
The matter carries personal significance for the petitioner, Charvi S., who experiences a 40 percent visual impairment. According to the court filings, her health condition is directly linked to the fact that her parents were first cousins who married under prevailing customary practices within their community. Highlighting her own experience, the petitioner requested the court to intervene so that other children are protected from similar lifelong physical challenges.
Specifically, the petition seeks a judicial clarification or interpretation of Section 5(4) and Section 5(5) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955. It contends that any marriage within prohibited degrees or sapinda relationships should only take place after satisfying mandatory public health precautions. Proposed safeguards submitted to the court include mandatory pre-marital genetic counseling, full disclosure of medical risks, comprehensive medical testing, and official health certification before solemnization.
Court's Perspective on Legislative Boundaries and Personal Choice
Addressing the prayers in the petition, the Supreme Court bench emphasized that while the issue warrants attention, the court cannot act as a regulatory body over personal relationships. Chief Justice Surya Kant noted that decision-making regarding marriage is an exercise of individual choice, and the primary role of the state or public bodies should be to inform and educate citizens rather than impose outright judicial prohibitions. The bench recalled a historic precedent involving a marriage proposal where an individual was HIV-positive, reminding that courts have consistently recognized marriage as a personal matter.
The bench clarified that the notice sent to the Centre is strictly limited to seeking the government's stance on whether appropriate legislation should be framed or if mass awareness drives should be conducted across media platforms. The court reiterated that its objective is solely to draw the executive's focus toward the health risks involved, leaving policy decisions to the lawmaking authorities.
Understanding the Concept of Sapinda Relationships
Under Hindu law, the term 'sapinda' refers to individuals connected through blood lineage within specified generations. The legal framework under the Hindu Marriage Act defines sapinda relationship as extending up to three generations through the mother's line of descent and up to five generations through the father's line of descent. In calculating these generations, the individual concerned is counted as the first generation, moving upward through the family tree.
While Section 5 of the Hindu Marriage Act generally prohibits sapinda marriages unless validated by established custom or usage, the petition argues that custom should no longer override scientific evidence regarding genetic risks. The apex court's decision to seek the Centre's view marks a key step toward opening a broader policy discussion on balancing traditional matrimonial customs with public health imperatives.



















