The Supreme Court of India has initiated an internal probe after discovering that a petition filed by the Enforcement Directorate remained unlisted for hearing for nearly three years, despite prior judicial orders directing its placement before the bench. Expressing deep concern over the procedural lapse, a bench headed by Chief Justice Surya Kant directed the court's Secretary General to conduct a thorough factual inquiry to determine why the matter was held back from listing for such an extended period.
Judicial Bench Questions Procedural Delay
During the proceedings, Chief Justice Surya Kant questioned the handling of the case within the court administration, asking who ensured that the petition was not brought before the court for three full years. The bench emphasized that the Supreme Court Registry must provide a clear explanation for how such an oversight occurred. The matter pertains to a challenge brought by the central investigative agency against a lower court decision granting anticipatory bail to an accused person.
Timeline of the ED Legal Petition
The legal history of the petition dates back to early 2023, when the Enforcement Directorate challenged an order issued by the Punjab and Haryana High Court in January 2023. The apex court had initially issued a notice on the agency's plea in July 2023. Subsequently, in January 2024, the Supreme Court explicitly ordered that the case be listed for hearing in February 2024. However, despite the specific judicial directive, the petition failed to appear on the official cause list, prompting the bench to demand a comprehensive administrative report.
Arguments Presented During the Hearing
Senior Advocate Siddharth Dave, appearing for one of the parties in the matter, remarked during the hearing that such occurrences were atypical for the apex court, stating that nothing could be managed within the Supreme Court. However, the bench maintained its firm stance on identifying the exact cause of the listing failure. Meanwhile, the counsel representing the Enforcement Directorate informed the court that the trial in the underlying case had already commenced, with statements from eight witnesses recorded so far. The Supreme Court has directed the Registry to complete the inquiry and submit its findings regarding the delayed listing.



















