Should the legal framework surrounding marriages between close blood relatives undergo a fundamental change? Is it necessary for the government to take stringent legislative steps to safeguard children born from such unions against the severe hazards of genetic disorders? These crucial questions took center stage during a hearing before the Supreme Court. What makes this particular petition extraordinary is the identity of the petitioner herself, a young woman who was born to parents who are first cousins. The petitioner stated that she suffers from debilitating genetic illnesses and utilized her personal lived experience to demand the total removal of legal and customary exemptions that currently permit marriages among close blood relatives.
Supreme Court Asks Central Government to Explore Legislative Options
While presiding over the matter, the Supreme Court directed the central government to explore viable legislative options aimed at preventing marriages between close relatives. The primary concern of the bench centers on the heightened risk of congenital and genetic disorders in offspring born from such familial unions. The court noted that the administration could examine the feasibility of enacting specific legislation to address this issue. Furthermore, the bench acknowledged that marriages among close blood relatives remain prevalent within certain Muslim communities and select Hindu communities in South India. Moving forward, the government must evaluate what regulatory and legal measures can be implemented to minimize health risks for future generations.
PIL Filed by an NLSIU Student
This public interest litigation was brought forward by an LLB student studying at the National Law School of India University. The petitioner's parents share a first-cousin relationship, meaning they are bound by close consanguinity. According to the petition, the young woman herself suffers from serious health conditions, specifically photophobia and cone dystrophy. She leveraged her medical diagnosis as the cornerstone for arguing that existing legal allowances permitting marriages between close relatives deserve a comprehensive review. The petitioner urged the judiciary to strike down statutory and customary exemptions that facilitate such unions, arguing that the law must prioritize a child's fundamental right to a healthy life. The petition also raised a pertinent question regarding why legal exemptions persist when medical evidence consistently demonstrates elevated genetic risks associated with consanguineous marriages.
Elevated Risks of Genetic Diseases in Children
The petition outlines that offspring born from unions between close relatives face an increased susceptibility to autosomal recessive disorders. Such conditions typically manifest when a child inherits identical defective gene variants from both the mother and the father. Because close relatives share a higher degree of genetic overlap and similarities, the likelihood of transmitting hereditary illnesses to their children rises significantly. The petition also highlights various congenital deformities, disabilities, and critical infant health concerns. However, this does not imply that every single marriage between close relatives will automatically produce an affected child, as the actual risk depends on a multitude of genetic and medical factors. To mitigate these very risks, the petitioner pressed for legislative amendments.
Understanding Photophobia and Cone Dystrophy
The specific medical conditions cited by the petitioner include photophobia and cone dystrophy. Photophobia is a medical condition where an individual's eyes exhibit an abnormal sensitivity to light, making bright environments painful and even normal lighting quite uncomfortable. Conversely, cone dystrophy is a retinal disorder that directly impacts the cone photoreceptor cells within the eye. These specific cells are vital for color vision and visual acuity, and when they are compromised, individuals experience severe difficulties with color recognition and clarity of sight. Following these proceedings, attention now shifts to the central government's official stance, as the Supreme Court's observations threaten to ignite a broader national debate surrounding consanguineous marriages and the genetic health of children.





















