New Delhi: In a significant legal ruling, the Delhi High Court has clarified that an Aadhaar card cannot be accepted as a conclusive proof of a person's date of birth. The court emphasized that while the Aadhaar number is designed to establish an individual's identity, it lacks the legal backing to serve as verification for one's exact birth date. This observation was made during the adjudication of a service dispute involving a female employee who contested her abrupt termination and retirement.
Justice Manoj Kumar Ohri, delivering the verdict on November 13, noted that under the Aadhaar Act, 2016, the identification number is solely recognized as proof of identity. The statutory framework contains no provision that permits accepting it as an authentic document for verifying when someone was born.
Dispute Involving Termination and Discrepant Records
The core dispute centered around a female employee whose services were terminated by her employer in 2017. The management argued that the worker had reached the retirement age of 58, relying on the date of birth May 20, 1959, as reflected in her Aadhaar card. The employee challenged this action, maintaining that according to the records maintained by the Employees' State Insurance Corporation (ESIC), her actual date of birth was May 20, 1960. Based on the ESIC records, she contended that she had not attained retirement age in 2017.
Reference to UIDAI Guidelines and Lack of Independent Verification
The court also brought into focus an office memorandum issued by the UIDAI on December 20, 2018. The memorandum explicitly states that the date of birth recorded on an Aadhaar card is based on documents provided by the cardholder or through self-declaration. The bench observed that in this particular case, there was no independent corroborative document on record to substantiate the birth date printed on the Aadhaar card. Furthermore, the employer had obtained the employee's Aadhaar card barely two months prior to terminating her services.
Premature Retirement Set Aside by the Court
Ruling in favor of the employee, the High Court held that when her official ESIC records consistently showed her birth date as May 20, 1960, the employer could not arbitrarily cut short her service by a year based on a conflicting date found on an Aadhaar card. The court concluded that the employee had not reached the mandatory retirement age when she was let go in 2017.
This judicial pronouncement clarifies the legal standing of documents when discrepancies arise between an Aadhaar card and established service records. Prior to this ruling, the Allahabad High Court had also observed that an Aadhaar card is not proof of age while dealing with matters concerning marriage registrations and school transfer certificates in Uttar Pradesh.



















