During the Shanghai Cooperation Organisation (SCO) summit held in India, Pakistani Minister Musadik Malik faced intense and sharp questioning from Indian media representatives. Accompanied by Farhat Ayesha, a senior Pakistani Foreign Service officer and Director General (SCO), the minister found himself pressed on critical bilateral matters including terrorism and water sharing agreements. As reporters launched direct queries, the accompanying diplomat grew visibly anxious about potential unscripted remarks that could trigger a diplomatic controversy on Indian soil. Camera footage recorded Farhat Ayesha attempting to intervene and silence the minister on two separate occasions during the interaction. However, Malik chose to disregard the diplomat's warnings and pressed ahead with his responses, highlighting the underlying tension within the visiting delegation.
Sharp Questioning on Terrorism and Diplomatic Intervention
The first flashpoint occurred when Indian journalists directly confronted Musadik Malik regarding Pakistan's actions to curb cross-border terrorism. As journalists pressed for concrete steps taken by Islamabad, Farhat Ayesha immediately stepped in to interrupt the exchange. Sensing the sensitivity of the query, she attempted to stop the minister from answering. Malik, however, gestured to her and said, "Wait a moment," before continuing with his response. Addressing the subject, Malik maintained that discussions regarding terrorism should be grounded in hard evidence rather than allegations. He further proposed the establishment of a joint or shared platform where both nations could address security concerns through structured dialogue.
Confrontation Over Past Controversial Statements
The interaction turned even more heated when reporters brought up Malik's past rhetoric concerning the Indus Waters Treaty and relations with India. Journalists specifically reminded him of a previous aggressive statement in which he had spoken of 'cutting off hands.' The revival of this controversial remark prompted Farhat Ayesha to intervene for a second time, attempting to abruptly end the line of questioning before the minister could elaborate. Undeterred by his colleague's caution, Malik firmly turned to her and remarked, "Madam please, I know." He then proceeded to address the journalists, refusing to bypass the controversial point raised by the press core.
Position on Bilateral Talks and the Indus Waters Treaty
Throughout the session, Malik consistently returned to the themes of evidence-based discussion and diplomatic engagement. When questioned about the prospect of resuming bilateral talks with New Delhi, he asserted that Pakistan remains open to dialogue provided an official invitation is extended by India. Regarding the Indus Waters Treaty, he noted that no formal invite had been received for fresh negotiations, but affirmed willingness to participate should India initiate talks. Despite the minister's attempts to portray an open stance, the repeated physical interventions by diplomat Farhat Ayesha dominated attention, laying bare the Pakistani delegation's underlying apprehension of making unscripted slips during their high-profile visit to India.



















